epitaph reviews 1989
“Epitaph was heard for the first time Saturday night at Alice Tully Hall at a concert that ranks with the most memorable jazz events of the decade.” The New York Times: Premiere of a Boisterous Jazz Overview by Mingus; June 5, 1989 by Jon Pareles
“Epitaph' is pure Mingus: rich and sonorous, by turns humorous and achingly beautiful. "Epitaph" is the big event of the year in jazz. Rolling Stone
"...a monumental composition by the protean jazz bassist. The vivid result resembles its creator: difficult but dazzling. Time Magazine
"Like Duke Ellington, he sought to transcend the song-and-dance origins of jazz and integrate composition and improvisation in extended orchestral forms. "Epitaph," a two hour symphonic work that Mingus said he wrote for his tombstone, is proof of his genius.” People
"Gorgeous melodies give way to dark, dense sonorities; tempestuous pronouncements contrast with gospel-inspired petitions. It reflects perfectly Mingus's restless, exploratory nature.” Billboard
"...As one plays and replays it, one gradually catches the musical quotations, the structural shifts, the internal byplay and repeating motifs that make "Epitaph" a landmark composition. The romantic ballads within "Epitaph" – "The Soul' and 'Noon Night' – are just waiting to become standards. The Washington Post
"...a mammoth work ... a crowning achievement. Chicago Sun-Times
"This recording is ... a revelation ... remarkably coherent and intensely dramatic... a performance that will be talked about for years."Hot House: "Epitaph" is a vital, living document of a dream shared...For decades to come, listeners the world over will be warmed by the fire of this 18-movement masterpiece.” Entertainment Weekly
"...as the recent Columbia recording confirms, there's nothing else like "Epitaph" in the history of jazz. At its best, "Epitaph" integrates all its materials...into one vision. As Gunther Schuller concludes: "It's uncategorizable. It has nothing to do anymore with "jazz" or "classical" music, or anything. It's just Mingus." The Boston Phoenix
“It marks the first advance in the composition of large-scale jazz works since Duke Ellington’s 1943 “Black, Brown and Beige…” The New Yorker Jazz: Mingus Regained; August 21, 1989 by Whitney Balliett
“Charles Mingus’s ‘Epitaph’ is an overwhelming composition, flooding the listener with more themes and variations than can be digested in a first listening” The Washington Post “Charles Mingus’s Epic ‘Epitaph’; June 6, 1989 by Geoffrey Himes
“More than two hours long, the late Charles Mingus’ ‘Epitaph’ blends atonal passages and improvised solos in a style as challenging as Stravinsky’s ‘Rite of Spring’”“The Best of ‘90”; December 31, 1990“Composer-musicologist Gunther Schuller leads an all-star big band in a definitive live performance of the monumental suite – raw, raucous and richly textured – by a pioneer figure of modern jazz.” Time June, 1989 by John Elson
“Charles Mingus tributes highlight of 12th Jazz Festival”; September 3, 1990 by Lloyd Sachs “The beautifully controlled playing covered a broad range of styles and emotions. A work about hope and overcoming, pride and self-testing, and just plain living, ‘Epitaph’ will only grow in mastery in the years to come.” Chicago Sun-Times
“‘Epitaph’, Charles Mingus’ massive sound collage, is an extraordinary orchestral explosion, a passionate drama filled with thunder and sweetness and mystery.” San Francisco Chronicle "Mingus ‘Epitaph’ at Davies; June 10, 1991 by Jesse Hamlin
Epitaph reviews 2007
“The highlight of this Symphony Center jazz season occurred Friday evening: Charles Mingus’ Epitaph,” played by a 31-piece band conducted by Gunther Schuller. Mingus intended this 2 1⁄2 - hour composition to be monumental, and it surely was. Its many contrary, simultaneous events approached Charles Ives’ wildest creations, while its harmonic richness and variety of sonic effects approached Duke Ellington, and it included enough melodies to stuff several Mahler symphonies.” Chicago Sun-Times Review Mingus’ ‘Epitaph’ elephantine, messy yet often a delight; May 21, 2007 by John Litweiler
“Though Charles Mingus long has been revered as a fearlessly iconoclastic musician, listeners cannot take his full measure until they’ve heard his “Epitaph.”“For though Mingus remains justly admired for tunes such as “Goodbye Pork Pie Hat,” the scale of his ambition and breadth of his achievement in “Epitaph” place him at the pinnacle of American composition. For starters, several movements in “Epitaph” are so daringly conceived and eloquently articulated that they stand on their own as brilliantly realized works.”“…Mingus in “Epitaph” addresses practically the whole of jazz history, from his bracingly dissonant reinterpretation of Jelly Roll Morton’s “Wolverine Blues” to his exquisitely detailed reimagining Thelonious Monk’s “Well, You Needn’t.” “Charles Mingus’ monumental ‘Epitaph’ gets full treatment”; May 21, 2007 by Howard Reich Chicago Tribune
”The word “scope” only begins to define the magnitude of “Epitaph.” Directing 31 musicians, Schuller conducted a program that ran more than 2 1⁄2 (not including intermission) and featured more than 3,400 bars of music. The music ranges from simple to chaotic, dissonant to soulful. It was epic and well worth the cost and the drive from Pittsburgh.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette “Short Takes: Mingus’ ‘Epitaph,” ‘Diary of Anne Frank’; May 1, 2007 by Nate Guidry
“Too bad Mingus wasn’t around to bask in the hard-earned standing ovation for “Epitaph,” a monumental achievement unparalleled in the annals of jazz.” The Plain Dealer “Mingus marathon a moving ‘Epitaph’”; April 29, 2007 by John Soeder
“Epitaph turns out to be a perfect title since it defines Mingus as an original synthesis of the past, present and future of music – reaching out to the radical avant-garde with wandering dissonances worthy of Charles Ives; looking back to gospel, Jelly Roll Morton, Vernon Duke, bebop, Mingus’s own greatest hits (“Better Get It In Your Soul”), and above all, Ellington.” Variety.com “Epitaph by Charles Mingus”; May 17, 2007 by Richard S. Ginell
“…intimate linkages between improvisations and ensemble passages that characterize all of Mingus’ music, regardless of the size of the ensemble, the sardonic humor that urges him to include quotes – within the same piece – from Dvorak’s “Humoresque No. 7,” David Rose’s “Holiday for Strings” and Duke Ellington’s “Reminiscing in Tempo”, the incipient feeling of approaching chaos, of spontaneity that could break out in any direction at any time.” Los Angeles Times (online) “Gunther Schuller tackles Mingus’ ‘Epitaph’ at Disney”; May 18, 2007 by Don Heckman
“Everywhere you looked in this band, there was a genius – from the great Boris Kozlov standing next to the great Christian McBride in place of the Mingus bass fiddle to Kenny Rampton, Jack Walrath, and Ryan Kisor in the trumpet section, Ronnie Cuber and Craig Handy among the saxophones handling the murky middle parts.” The Hollywood Reporter “Old grudge is laid to rest amid Mingus masterpiece”; May 21, 2007 by Tony Gieske
More ONLINE REVIEWS OF 1989 tour
Reviving An 'Epitaph,' A Symphony By Mingus by Jon Pareles, New York Times June 2, 1989
A Premiere by Mingus, Big, Boisterous and Jazzy by Jon Pareles, New York Times June 5, 1989
Mingus's Epic 'Epitaph' by Geoffrey Himes, The Washington Post June 6, 1989
The Year's Best by Jon Pareles, New York Times December 24, 1989
Jazz fest lineup Charles Mingus' `Epitaph' to premiere in September by Howard Reich Chicago Tribune Mar 22, 1990
Belated Life for an Epic "Epitaph' Geoffrey Himes, The Washington Post Jun 13, 1990
Jazzmen join in Mingus `Epitaph' by Lloyd Sachs, Chicago Sun-Times August 26, 1990
An Epitaph Comes Back to Life: Charles Mingus' long-forgotten jazz masterwork is getting its dueby John Elson, Time Magazine September 10, 1990
Best of Music Time Magzine Dec. 31, 1990
Mingus's 'Epitaph' by a 30-Piece Band by John O'Conner, New York Times January 18, 1991
Orchestral 'Epitaph' for Jazz Composer by Geofrey Himes, The Washington Post June 7, 1991
Annual Top 10 Lists Of Weekend Music Critics The Washington Post Dec 27, 1991